Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


FIFA Qatar 2022 plan would ‘exacerbate’ Gulf tensions

FIFA President Gianni Infantino hails the support of a feasibility study unveiled in Miami last week for his plan to expand the Qatar World Cup to 48 teams with additional host countries © AFP/File / RHONA WISE

DOHA, Qatar, Mar 19 – FIFA President Gianni Infantino’s plan to expand the Qatar World Cup to 48 teams and increase the number of host countries risks worsening existing Gulf diplomatic tensions, claim analysts.

The ambitious expansion proposal — which Infantino has optimistically stated might help Middle East peace — could see the extra matches hosted in Kuwait and Oman in 2022.

But far from making a politically turbulent region more harmonious, analysts say FIFA’s proposal could deepen regional fissures and leave Kuwait and Oman, as well as Qatar, open to further political arm-twisting from the regional power bloc of Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Bahrain.

“There is a very real risk that expanding the World Cup to include Kuwait and Oman would make these two countries vulnerable to the same sort of regional pressure Qatar has faced since 2017,” said Kristian Coates Ulrichsen, a research fellow at Rice University.

“Particularly since Kuwait and Oman also have followed their own approaches to regional affairs.”

Number of teams that qualified for the World Cup finals since 1930, with a new format foreseen for 2022 and 2026 © AFP / Frédéric HUGON, Paz PIZARRO

It could also foster resentment in those countries missing out on games, notably Saudi Arabia and the UAE, Ulrichsen added.

“The idea of a regional World Cup that includes Kuwait and Oman but not Saudi Arabia or the UAE would likely be a cause of considerable bitterness in Riyadh and Abu Dhabi.”

– ‘Makes no sense’ –

Since June 2017, World Cup host Qatar has been blockaded by the Saudi-led countries in a bitter political spat, one of the worst Gulf diplomatic conflicts for years.

Saudi Arabia and its allies, which also include Egypt, accuse Qatar of promoting terrorism and being too close to Riyadh’s great political and religious rival, Tehran.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Qatar denies its rivals’ allegations and accuses them of seeking regime change in Doha.

The fan disturbances that accompanied the United Arab Emirates’ home defeat to Qatar in the Asian Cup semi-final in January augur ill for hopes an expanded 2022 World Cup might boost regional peace © AFP/File / Giuseppe CACACE

For 21 months — and counting — Saudi Arabia and it allies have imposed a political, economic and travel boycott around Qatar which shows few signs of easing.

Notably though, the blockading countries do not include the traditionally neutral Gulf states of Kuwait and Oman, which have been left to tread a politically precarious line.

Andreas Krieg of King’s College London, who has worked as an adviser to the Qatari government, said Kuwait and Oman “both have issues with Saudi and the UAE”.

Tensions have flared between Kuwait and Saudi Arabia over the management of jointly owned oil fields, while Oman has faced allegations that it has allowed Iranian arms shipments through its territory to Huthi rebels fighting a Saudi-led coalition in Yemen.

At the same time, Kuwait has been the regional negotiator in the crisis, while Oman is an economic winner from the conflict, its trade with Qatar jumping 240 per cent since 2016, according to Doha.

“The Gulf dispute as it exists would be further exacerbated by having a World Cup over three countries,” added Krieg.

Qatar’s ruler Emir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad al-Thani hands his Kuwaiti counterpart Emir Sheikh Sabah al-Ahmad Al-Sabah a signed Qatari national team jersey in a display of the alliances at play in the Gulf © KUWAIT EMIRI DIWAN/AFP

He said FIFA proposals to share the Qatar World Cup with Kuwait and Oman would reinforce the feeling that the Gulf has split into two competing blocs of three countries, with Saudi, UAE and Bahrain on the other side.

“From a political point of view, it [expansion] doesn’t make sense.”

Even if Qatar is forced to share its World Cup, the first in the Middle East, it is unlikely to please Riyadh or Abu Dhabi, adds Krieg.

“I don’t see how Saudi and the UAE get anything out of that,” he says.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

– Football won’t solve crisis –

Yet FIFA’s plans to expand the 2022 World Cup appear to be gaining support among some football administrators.

The results of a much-vaunted FIFA “feasibility study”, announced at a meeting of football’s governing body last week in Miami, backed expansion in Qatar.

“We came to the conclusion, yes it’s feasible to move from 32 to 48 teams at the World Cup provided certain conditions are met,” Infantino said, declaring himself “happy” with the finding.

A final decision will be announced in Paris in June, and while the expansion plan has been gaining a seemingly irresistible momentum, some remain unconvinced.

Europe’s governing body, UEFA, said expansion would create “many problems” and was “not realistic”.

Campaigners warned FIFA not to neglect its own newly imposed standards on human rights when awarding World Cup host status.

Any expansion would see an extra 16 matches played over the duration of the 28-day tournament and there are concerns over whether stadiums and infrastructure in Kuwait and Oman would meet exacting FIFA tournament standards.

Emirati fans will get nothing out of an expanded 2022 World Cup, even if their bitter rival Qatar is forced to share its tournament, the first in the Middle East © AFP/File / KHALED DESOUKI

With so many issues, it is difficult to see any diplomatic dividend from the World Cup, said James Dorsey, a researcher at Singapore’s S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies and author of “The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer”.

“I think there’s zero chance,” he said.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

“The Gulf crisis is not going to be solved by playing football.”


More on Capital Sports


NAIROBI, Kenya, Oct 27 – DStv and GOtv subscribers are in for a treat of the world’s best football this week as the 2020-21...


NAIROBI, Kenya, Sep 6 – Gentrix Shikangwa scored with two minutes left as Vihiga Queens sailed to the final of the CECAFA regional qualifiers...


NAIROBI, Kenya, May 25 – There is light at the end of the tunnel. After failed promises over the last three years since its...


NAIROBI, Kenya, Aug 13 – Kenya’s history making Daniel Adongo, the first Kenyan to play in America’s National Football League (NFL), is now living...

© 2023 Capital Digital Media. Capital Group Limited. All Rights Reserved