Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Raphael Tuju/CFM -FILE


Tuju faces backlash over security privilege remark on judges

Tuju, while speaking on NTV Tonight, claimed those celebrating the annulment of the Building Bridges Initiative (BBI) constitutional amendment process by the Constitutional Court on May 13 were, “dancing of the graves of victims of post-election violence.”

NAIROBI, Kenya, May 18 – Jubilee Party Secretary General Raphael Tuju faced backlash on Monday night after suggesting security services offered to judges by the State were a privilege which judicial officers should take into account while issuing decrees.

Tuju, while speaking on NTV Tonight, claimed those celebrating the annulment of the Building Bridges Initiative (BBI) constitutional amendment process by the Constitutional Court on May 13 were, “dancing of the graves of victims of post-election violence.”

“Judges should learn the word ‘interdependence’ because as soon as they finish a ruling, they need policemen to escort them home,” the Secretary General of the governing party said in remarks that angered proponents of judicial independence, a key tenet of the Constitution (2010).

In a rejoinder, Law Society of Kenya (LSK) President Nelson Havi dismissed Tuju’s assertions as ridiculous saying judges have a right to security.

“Raphael Tuju, hear and get me loud and clear. Your buffoonery seems to know no limit. Judges volunteer to serve in an Arm of Government. Their security is not a privilege but a right. This is not Uganda in the 70s. Cross that line again and you will live to regret it,” Havi, who led the petitioners’ legal team against BBI, fired back.

His remarks were echoed by Esther Ang’awa, an LSK Council Member, who said the BBI process did not resolve past grievances including manipulation of electoral processes.

“Did BBI open the IEBC servers? Did BBI address the transmission of results debacle?” she posed.

“Raphael Tuju is currently on NTV saying those celebrating the High Court ruling on BBI are dancing on the graves of those who died during post election violence. That marks the end of my viewing tonight,” Gabriel Oguda, a columnist on a local daily, said.

Tuju’s remarks came on a day the State filed a notice of appeal against the judgment issued by a five-judge Constitutional Court bench which in addition to finding the BBI process unconstitutional, ruled that President Uhuru Kenyatta had violated Chapter 6 of the Constitution.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

“Uhuru Muigai Kenyatta has contravened Chapter 6 of the Constitution, and specifically Article 73(1)(a)(i), by initiating and promoting a constitutional change process contrary to the provisions of the Constitution on amendment of the Constitution,” the bench declared.

The BBI constitutional review process was found to have fallen short of the Primary Constituent Power, the court holding that the President overreached his mandate in promoting constitutional changes under a popular initiative.

In a unanimous judgment, Justices Prof Joel Ngugi, George Odunga, Jairus Ngaah, Chacha Mwita and Matheka Mumbua also upheld the basic structure doctrine rendering certain clauses of the Constitution unamendable, a finding fiercely criticized by Tuju.

The court noted that the basic structure of the constitution could only be amended by invoking a four-phased process entailing, “civic education; public participation and collation of views; Constituent Assembly debate; and ultimately, a referendum.”

The bench also held that the electoral agency, IEBC, lacked the statutory quorum to verify signatures submitted by BBI promoters in favour of the amendment process.

A BBI steering committee gazetted in January 2020 was also declared an unconstitutional entity, the court holding that it lacked the legal capacity to initiate constitutional changes under Article 257 which sets out conditions precedent for an amendment through a popular initiative.


More on Capital News


Prague (AFP), Oct 7 – EU leaders wrestled on Friday to come up with a plan to tackle soaring energy costs as they struggled...


Paris (AFP), Oct 7 – Iran said Friday an investigation into the death in custody of Mahsa Amini found she lost her life to...


Na Klang (Thailand) (AFP), Oct 7 – Thailand’s King Maha Vajiralongkorn on Friday visited a hospital treating those wounded in a gun and knife...


NAIROBI, Kenya, Oct 7 – The Kenya Universities and Colleges Central Placement Services (KUCCPS) has opened its portal for placement of government sponsored students...


Oslo (AFP), Oct 7 – Human rights watchdogs from Russia, Ukraine and Belarus won the Nobel Peace Prize on Friday, with the jury criticising...


Washington (AFP), Oct 7 – US President Joe Biden signed an executive order on Friday designed to protect the privacy of personal data transfers...


NAIROBI, Kenya, Oct 7 – The Senate battle to oversight expenditure at the county level has received a major boost after the Supreme Court...


NAIROBI, Kenya October 7 – Former President Uhuru Kenyatta says he will skip the Ethiopian peace talks in South Africa set for Saturday due...