Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

top
KRA Headquarters at Times Tower in Nairobi. /CFM-FILE.

Fifth Estate

Why minimum tax is an idea worth pursuing

The newly introduced minimum tax has been greeted with mixed reactions, of course, strong
passions in opposite directions. The opponents of this nagging idea argue that this is a tax on losses while the proponents argue that “losses” have to be taxed.

There are two contrasting perspectives to losses raising fundamental questions on our business environment and reporting culture, probably with the new tax deeper issues will emerge.

What’s new with minimum tax? Businesses are now being charged to tax on gross receipts at a marginal rate of 1%. Conventionally businesses are taxed on their profits, that option still exists provided the tax on profits are more than tax on gross receipts.

Taxing businesses on profits as it has always been has shown that loss-making entities comfortably escape the taxman’s noose.

Bear in mind that the onus of determining profits or losses rests on the taxpayer. The underlying notion in minimum tax is that every business is selling and further sales can be objectively determined.

Here comes the argument by the opposing side, that the new taxes will ruin loss making entities.

In my view, there are three types of loss-making entities to address here. First are businesses
perpetually making losses on book but by any other standard they are flourishing. How they
survive successive periods of loss-making, they know, we know, the tax man seems to have
known, they are the targets of this new tax.

Second category are businesses in capital intensive sectors and volatile environments like mining which by their nature experience oscillations between profits and losses.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The drafters of this law seem to have had this spirit by exempting the extractive industry, in other jurisdictions like Tanzania they exempt agriculture. My take is that these sectors be identified and be accommodated in the scope of exemption.

My third categorization is genuinely loss making business, that’s a possibility of some enterprise owners hanging on to loss making ventures hoping against hope.

The wisdom of Konosuke Matsushita a Japanese philosopher and founder of Panasonic Electronics gives courage. He quips “If we cannot make a profit, that means we are committing a sort of crime against society. We take society’s capital, we take their people, we take their materials, yet without a good profit, we are using precious resources that could be better used elsewhere”.

I concur with Konosuke Matsushita, persons holding on to productive resources, masquerading as business people should be urged to release their capital. That’s a conversation for another day especially with some rural dwellers claiming to be farmers. Minimum tax can initiate that debate.

Another perspective to minimum tax is the reintroduction of turnover tax. Businesses with
annual turnover of less than Sh50 million fall in the turnover tax regime; minimum tax is for
entities that are not registered with Turnover tax.

It is not a coincidence that the two taxes are
charged at 1% of the gross receipts. If smaller businesses must pay taxes at 1% then their larger counterparts should at least pay the same. This addresses two fundamental issues in taxation, fairness and closing loopholes for tax evasion.

If loss-making entities have always been here with us, what have the lobby groups, policymakers and industry players been doing about it? Let’s expand the scope of this conversation beyond taxation.

The writer is a lecturer at KCA University

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.
Comments
Advertisement

More on Capital News

COUNTDOWN TO 2022

Nairobi, Kenya, June 28-Azimio La Umoja One Kenya Coalition Presidential flag bearer Raila Odinga has defended President Uhuru Kenyatta’s administration against accusations of failing...

Afghanistan

Kabul [Afghanistan], June 24 -In the wake of the tragic earthquake that struck Afghanistan on June 22, Ministry of External Affairs Joint Secretary (PAI),...

World

New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi and United Arab Emirates (UAE) President Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan met Tuesday in Abu Dhabi, where both...

AUGUST 9 COUNTDOWN

NAIROBI, Kenya, June 28 – Azimio-One Kenya Alliance presidential candidate Raila Odinga has called on his arch political rival Deputy President William Ruto to...

World

Paris (AFP), Jun 28 – France’s lower house of parliament on Tuesday agreed to pick an MP from President Emmanuel Macron’s centrist coalition as...

August Elections

NAIROBI, Kenya, Jun 28 – Azimio-One Kenya coalition Presidential candidate Raila Odinga now says he is ready to concede defeat in the August Presidential...

August Elections

NAIROBI, Kenya, Jun 28 – Azimio-One Kenya Presidential candidate Raila Odinga and his running mate Martha Karua have pledged to lower the cost of...

August Elections

NAIROBI, Kenya, Jun 28 – Azimio-One Kenya coalition Presidential candidate Raila Odinga and his running mate Martha Karua say their government will use money...