NEW DELHI, Jul 24 – The percentage of Indians living below the poverty line has fallen to 22 percent from 37 percent in just seven years, according to official data released Tuesday, but the figures were dismissed by critics as “deeply flawed”.
Calculating poverty is a hugely controversial topic in Asia’s third-largest economy and the debate over the latest numbers could prove particularly heated as they come ahead of an election year in which the Congress government is seeking a third term.
The poverty rate fell by a robust 15 percentage points to 22 percent in 2011-12 from 37 percent in 2004-05, the figures from India’s influential Planning Commission showed.
While economic growth slowed last year to a decade low of five percent, the Congress government, in power since 2004, argues near double-digit expansion in previous years has driven a dramatic reduction in poverty in the country of 1.2 billion people.
The number of extremely poor people in absolute terms tumbled to 269.3 million in 2011-12 from 403.7 million in 2004-05, the commission said.
According to the commission, anyone with less than 33 rupees (55 cents) to spend a day in urban areas and less than 27 rupees a day in rural areas is counted as under the poverty line.
“These figures are deeply flawed and unrealistic about the actual conditions in the country,” Miloon Kothari, former UN Special Rapporteur on the right to adequate housing, told AFP.
“If you see the situation in the cities and villages it is quite clear there has not been such a huge reduction in poverty,” Kothari, now a leading Indian human rights activist, said.
According to the World Bank, nearly 70 percent of India’s population lives on less than $2 a day — often cited as the baseline for poverty in the country.
India’s poverty estimates are used to determine public access to welfare benefits such as subsidised food.
The figures will be used by India’s states to start identifying beneficiaries for the populist government’s flagship cheap food scheme that it sees as key to its hopes of re-election.
Congress party chief Sonia Gandhi has asked states to start rolling out next month the subsidised food programme, which will be the world’s largest, offering grains at a fraction of market prices.
“State governments can use the updated data for identifying beneficiaries,” Food Minister K.V. Thomas said, though the food security scheme will reach far more than the 269.3 million people identified as below the poverty line.
It will offer grains to nearly 70 percent of the population, or 820 million people.
Despite being an aspiring superpower and boasting a burgeoning class of urban rich, hundreds of millions of people still face a lack of food, clean water and proper housing.
Malnutrition is widespread with 46 percent of India’s children below the age of three malnourished, UNICEF says.
The commission’s figures were based on an analysis of data gathered from roughly 100,000 households by the National Sample Survey Organization looking at spending on food, healthcare and other items.
The commission noted the poverty numbers could be revised upward based on findings of a committee led by top government adviser C. Rangarajan which is reviewing the methodology for measuring poverty and is due to report in 2014.
The committee was set up to reassess the way of estimating the number of poor after critics accused the government of trying to massage poverty figures down for political gain.
But even if the percentage of poor increases, the “rate of decline (between 2004-05 and 2011-12) would be similar”, the committee said.