Nestle challenges noodles ban in Indian court

June 11, 2015 12:05 pm


Nestle has been selling its Maggi brand in India for over three decades/AFP
Nestle has been selling its Maggi brand in India for over three decades/AFP
MUMBAI, Jun 11 – Nestle said Thursday it is challenging a ban imposed by India on its hugely popular Maggi instant noodles brand after tests showed they contained excessive levels of lead.

Nestle said it had approached the high court in the western city of Mumbai seeking a judicial review of a June 5 order from the government’s food safety regulator banning the product.

“Nestle India Limited has today approached the Hon’ble Bombay High Court raising issues of interpretation of the Food Safety and Standards Act 2011,” said a statement posted on the company’s website.

Nestle had already announced it was pulling the product from sale when the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) imposed a ban following similar moves by some state governments.

On Thursday the company, which says the noodles are safe to eat, said it would keep the product off store shelves despite the court action.

The regulator announced last week it was banning both the production and sale of Maggi noodles after tests by some states found lead levels above statutory limits.

It said the presence of lead beyond permissible levels could make the product “unsafe and hazardous”, citing risks of damage to the kidneys and the nervous system.

The safety scare is a huge blow to the company, which has been selling its Maggi brand for over three decades in India, and has 80 percent of the country’s instant noodle market.

Shares in Nestle India, a subsidiary of the Swiss-based giant, fell more than 9.0 percent on the Bombay Stock Exchange last week as the controversy escalated.

– Government seeks damages –

Global chief executive Paul Bulcke flew to India last week to try to reassure consumers over the safety scare, telling a press conference on Friday that the noodles were “safe for consumption”.

But the move failed to convince India’s government, which on Monday said it would seek damages from Nestle for false advertising of the product — marketed as a quick and healthy snack.

The scandal led to renewed scrutiny of packaged food products in India, where Unilever this week said it was pulling its Knorr Chinese instant noodles from sale.

Hindustan Unilever Limited (HUL), the company’s Indian branch, said it had taken the decision because its application for approval for the product range from the FSSAI was still pending.

Nestle, which markets a huge range of food items from Nescafe instant coffee to KitKat bars, said last week that Maggi noodles would return to the market “as soon as the current situation is clarified”.

Maggi noodles grew increasingly popular as more and more Indians moved away from their homes to study or seek work.

It emerged as one of India’s five most trusted brands in a consumer survey conducted last year.

Several celebrities have endorsed Maggi over the years, including Bollywood superstar Amitabh Bachchan.

Nestle said it was also challenging a separate order from the state government of Maharashtra, of which Mumbai is the capital.

The Mumbai court will hear submissions from both sides on June 18, according to a listing on its website.


Latest Articles

Most Viewed